top of page

Jeepers Creepers (2001) Review: Still Terrifying, but the Writing Hasn't Aged Nearly as Well

25 minutes ago
13 min read

Spoiler Warning: This review discusses major plot developments, character deaths, and the ending of Jeepers Creepers (2001).



Film Credits & Cast


Title: Jeepers Creepers (2001) | Director and writer: Victor Salva | Starring: Justin Long (Darry Jenner), Gina Philips (Trish Jenner), Patricia Belcher (Jezelle Gay Hartman), and Jonathan Breck (the Creeper).


BLAKWATCH Rating: 7.7/10


I've seen Jeepers Creepers probably five or six times in my life. I caught it on television one night, right from the beginning, not really expecting anything. And this movie blew me away. The look of it, the feeling of it, these specific images that I can still see in my head all these years later. That's the kind of horror movie this was for me.


Watching it again on purpose, with my critic hat on, is a whole different experience. Some problems I noticed before, but they hit differently now. Other things I didn't notice at all. We've seen a lot of movies since 2001, and we're a different audience. We know more about storytelling, we recognize tropes quicker, and we're not as willing to let certain things slide. When a movie is this close to being great, I want it to go ahead and be great all the way through. Don't tease me.


So here's where I landed. Jeepers Creepers is still good. It's still genuinely scary, and in some places it does horror better than movies being made today. But the Creeper himself holds up a whole lot better than some of the writing around him.



There Is Something Terrifying About an Empty Road in Broad Daylight


The setting is one of the first things I think about when I think about Jeepers Creepers. Those long, empty roads out in rural Florida, all that farmland, and no convenience store or gas station for miles. I love horror that takes place somewhere wide open like that. Not in the woods, not in some dark alley, but out in the countryside where it's beautiful and somehow already creepy.


And it's broad daylight! That's one of the coolest things about the opening. Darry and Trish are driving home from college, teasing each other, playing their little license-plate game, talking about a local legend. They feel like real brother and sister immediately. They pick at each other, but you can tell they're close. The movie doesn't waste much time establishing that relationship before the trouble starts.


Then you see the truck in the distance behind them.


That's unforgettable scene number one for me. That ugly, beat-up, fortified-looking truck creeping up behind them. You can't see who's driving it. The horn sounds like nothing you've ever heard, and then there's the BEATNGU license plate. The plate almost doesn't look real. And once you find out who owns this thing, you start asking all kinds of ridiculous questions. Does he register his truck? Does he buy gas? Does he fix the engine himself? Is he sitting at red lights somewhere? I love that the movie leaves you wondering.


I thought of Spielberg's Duel almost immediately. I saw that movie when I was young, and that trucker relentlessly terrorizing somebody on an empty road never left me. Jeepers Creepers taps into the same fear, but there's a whole other layer waiting for us. At this point we think it's some deranged serial killer in a truck. Nobody is expecting a winged creature.


Then we get to that abandoned church. He's dumping what looks like a bloodstained body into this pipe, and as Darry and Trish drive past, he turns and watches them. The way his head follows that car is burned into my memory. They saw him. He saw them. And you just know that was probably their last chance to get away without becoming part of his business.



When the Suspense Works, It Really Works


Darry going back to the church is where the bad horror-movie writing starts getting on my nerves. The film even has the siblings acknowledge that this is exactly the ridiculous thing people do in horror movies. Okay, you recognized the trope. You're still doing it, though.


And then he lets his sister dangle him down that extremely long pipe by his feet. For what? What was she supposed to do if something went wrong? Of course a rat startles him, she loses her grip, and down he goes. That long fall and the way his body hits the floor? I have never forgotten it. Terrible idea. Fantastic suspense.


Darry looks upward after his fall into the church's underground space.

The underground chamber is something else. Bodies stitched into the walls, old tools everywhere, this whole bizarre workshop the Creeper has built for himself. He isn't just killing people and eating what he wants. He's sewing them together, arranging them, collecting them, like somebody making a horrifying quilt. And sewing takes time! He only gets 23 days every 23 years.


How many feeding cycles did it take him to make all this? How long has that church been abandoned? How is he keeping these bodies from rotting? He's got hundreds down there, according to Darry. Is he doing all that work in his little 23-day window? At the end of the movie, he looks like a guy in his hobby shop just taking his sweet time.


Now, I don't need every answer. I actually love not knowing how he preserves the bodies, or whether there's something biological about him that lets him do it. Let my imagination go there. But once you give us the 23-day rule, I'm naturally going to wonder how he's finding the time to run this whole operation.


What doesn't work for me is the way this room is lit. Darry doesn't notice the wall full of bodies until something drips on his shoe and he finally looks up. But I'm looking at the room. It is not dark enough for that! The wall is curved around him and covered with bodies. You can see them around the edges of the shot before the reveal. Darry should be able to see them too. Later, in the holding cells at the police station, they do this exact kind of reveal the right way. There, you can only see what the flashlight illuminates. Here, the room itself is lit enough to give the whole trick away.


Don't get me wrong, though. That room scared me badly when I first saw it. Stitched-up human bodies covering the walls? That's a horrifying image, whether the reveal is staged convincingly or not.



Justin Long Deserves His Flowers


Justin Long communicates dread almost entirely through his eyes as he listens to Jezelle.

Can we please give Justin Long his flowers? Seriously. I know people think of horror acting as screaming, running, and making scared faces. But look at what this man is doing here. He's playing a real person going through something profoundly traumatic, and he takes that seriously.


When Darry comes out of that church, look at his eyes. They're glazed over. His face is tense and exhausted. He looks like somebody who has actually been through what we've just watched. Even when he's back in the car, he's not okay. He can barely get his words out. Now, the way he keeps refusing to communicate with Trish gets annoying, and we'll get to that, but the actual performance is extraordinary. He's acting the aftermath of fear, not just the moment something scares him.


And his eyes! This man has an exceptional ability to show emotion with his eyes. The wide, petrified stare, the glossy look when he's trying to process what Jezelle is telling him, that tension in his face. So it's especially interesting that the Creeper ends up wanting his eyes. The very feature Justin Long uses so powerfully throughout the movie is the part the monster takes.


I don't care what else I see Justin Long in. A little part of me is always going to go, 'That's Darry from Jeepers Creepers.' The hair, that Bannon shirt, those eyes. He made this character unforgettable to me.



The Creeper Is Almost Perfect


The Creeper's dark silhouette stands against a meat-market billboard while holding a severed head.

Now let's talk about the Creeper, because this is where the movie really wins me over. Jonathan Breck is fantastic as this thing. The way he moves, the way he hunts, the way he doesn't speak, the way he's both animalistic and clearly intelligent. I love almost every choice they made with this creature.


First of all, he's driving a truck. I love that! He's wearing this old hat and a heavy coat that makes him look like some bounty hunter from the 1800s. I'd been playing Red Dead Redemption 2, and it reminded me of Sadie Adler's bounty-hunter outfit. He loves his hat. He wears clothes he clearly doesn't need. He listens to music. He knows how to operate machinery. He might even be a mechanic, because that old truck looks terrible but runs like a charm. And yet underneath all this human behavior, he is absolutely not human.


And when those clothes come off? Wow. This thing looks like some combination of an insect, a bat, and a reptilian creature. The wet-looking skin, those claws, the wings, those fleshy frills around his face that open up. He looks like something that hatched out of an egg. The practical effects are so convincing that he genuinely looks alive, not like somebody standing there in a monster suit.

A closer view of the Creeper's detailed practical creature makeup.

And the performance sells every inch of it. He never has to give a speech. Watching him sniff and investigate people tells you plenty. That scene with the severed head is almost intimate in a really disturbing way. He's smelling it, licking it, almost making out with it. He looks like he's enjoying himself on some level that we don't even understand. It's horrible, and it's great horror.


Jezelle eventually explains that he scares people to smell something in their fear, and that the parts he eats become part of him. So the way he hunts has a purpose. He reminds me a little of the shirshu from Avatar: The Last Airbender, that creature that can track somebody by scent. Once a predator like that gets locked onto you, where are you going to hide? The police station? We've seen how well that works.


There's a little moment after Trish runs him over with the car that has stayed with me for years. His body is lying there, seemingly knocked out, and then those wings unfold and start flapping. Not flying, just moving. It reminds me of an injured moth whose wings are still twitching. It's such a small thing, but it makes him feel like an actual creature with an actual body.


I also love that they don't show us everything right away. First it's the truck. Then the hat and coat. Then we start seeing his face, his wings, and eventually his whole body. They let the mystery breathe instead of throwing the full monster at us in the first ten minutes.


The creature is exposed in the holding-cell area, stripped of its human-looking clothing.

The holding-cell scene might be the best example. Everything is dark except what the officer's flashlight catches. The Creeper is crouched down, naked, feeding on somebody, and we only see him from behind. Then you hear that horrible gulping, with his head and neck jerking around like an alligator swallowing something. What is his mouth even doing on the other side? We don't know, and that makes it worse. This is how you show a monster without giving the whole thing away.


I really think the Creeper should be a bigger horror icon than he is. With better handling of the franchise, this character could have been right up there in more conversations about great movie monsters. Just look at him.



The Writing Keeps Getting in Its Own Way


Here's the thing that's frustrating about Jeepers Creepers: the suspense is excellent, but the writing keeps getting in its own way. I didn't remember there being this much bad writing. I really didn't.


For one thing, how many times are we going to have someone calling another person's name and getting absolutely no answer? Darry shuts down when he's traumatized. Trish does it when she's scared. Once or twice, fine. That's human. But this movie uses it over and over until I'm sitting there going, 'Would you please answer somebody?' It's not scary anymore. It's irritating.


Then there's all the stuff people do because the movie wants a cool shot. Trish gets out of the car and wanders toward a police car where somebody has just been decapitated. Why are we getting out of the car? Then they sit there long enough to watch the Creeper practically make love to a severed head instead of driving away. At the cat lady's house, Trish screams at the woman to get away from him, but the woman is standing right there with them, holding a shotgun, nowhere near him! Sometimes the dialogue and the staging don't even match.


And then the cops are calling the fully exposed Creeper 'this guy' and talking about his strange body armor. Body armor? Have you looked at him? He has wings, claws, that whole face, and he's climbing walls! At that point you're not saying 'this guy' anymore. You're saying 'this thing.' The practical effects are so good that the dialogue sounds even more ridiculous.


I don't expect people in horror movies to make perfect decisions. People panic. People freeze. I know that. But there comes a point when you're asking me to ignore what the characters have already seen just so we can get to the next dramatic moment.


I don't mind the movie piling on the creepiness. Give me the weird cat lady, the nervous cats, the jump scares, the old abandoned church. It's a horror movie. Scare me every chance you get. What I don't love is the wind suddenly going still when the Creeper is near, or that song conveniently coming on the radio right before he attacks. Why? He's already scary. You don't need the weather or the radio announcing him. The old version of Jeepers Creepers playing in his workshop at the end is different. I like that because he actually seems to enjoy old music. That's a little window into his weird life.


As for the score, it's fine. Nothing about it stands out to me the way the visuals do. It's the setting, the suspense, and the Creeper himself that I remember.



Jezelle Deserved Better, and So Did the Siblings


Now we have to talk about Jezelle Gay Hartman, played by Patricia Belcher. She's clairvoyant. She sees things that have happened and things that are going to happen. She's not guessing. She just doesn't always know how to make sense of what she's seen. She knows about the cats, Darry's tattoo, the bodies, and things nobody could possibly know unless they were there. She's the closest thing these two have to an answer.


And what do Darry and Trish do? They keep treating this woman like she's the problem! Trish especially gets on my last nerve. Here's a woman telling you exactly what you've been going through, who knows things no stranger should know, and you keep interrupting her and asking why you're even listening to her? Are you serious? I would be glued to every word she said. This lady would be a godsend.


The moment I really couldn't stand was Darry grabbing Jezelle by the face, physically turning her head toward him, shaking her, demanding to know if her visions are ever wrong. I know he's scared. I know his life is on the line. Get your hands off this woman. She's an older lady who came here to help you. And after Darry is gone, Trish still treats her like she's barely worth acknowledging. That whole dynamic took me right out of caring about these characters.


Jezelle is also presented in that stereotypical "Magical Negro" tradition: the Black character with mystical knowledge who shows up outta nowhere to guide the white protagonists through something they don't understand. As a Black woman myself- watching this was not surprisingly cringe. She's largely there to deliver the lore and fill in the blanks for the main characters and the audience, and the way they speak to her and dismiss her is especially unpleasant to watch for me.


The main characters are such douchebags towards this women, that by the time the movie is winding down, I'm barely rooting for them anymore. And that's wild because I liked both of these siblings at the beginning. Darry is still easier for me to care about because Justin Long's acting is so good, but even he was losing me with how he treated Jezelle. I don't need every protagonist to be a wonderful person. But if you want me to be afraid they're going to die, you've got to give me somebody I actually want to see survive.


By the end, I was much more invested in watching the Creeper than I was in saving the people he was after. I really don't think that's what the movie was going for. But whatever.



Nowhere Is Safe, and That's the Film's Greatest Trick


One thing this movie is absolutely great at is making you feel unsafe everywhere. You start on a sunny country road. You make it to a diner with other people. You get a police escort. You finally reach the police station itself, a building full of armed officers. And none of it helps. Once this creature has decided it wants you, good luck finding somewhere safe.


That's the kind of horror I love. You don't have to be hiding in a basement at midnight. You can be out in daylight, surrounded by people, standing inside a police station, and still be in danger. The whole movie keeps taking away the places where you think you can finally relax.


And the lore gives you just enough to get your imagination going. Every 23rd spring, for 23 days, he feeds. What he eats becomes part of him. That's basically it, and I love it. Is he the only one? Does he come from a whole species? Is he ancient? Did he come from another planet, or somewhere deep inside the Earth? I don't know. I don't need the first movie to tell me. That's a whole universe of stories waiting to happen.


That countryside gives the whole thing its own flavor too. I get a little of that Children of the Corn feeling, and a little Stephen King in general. But Jeepers Creepers has its own lane. There's something especially frightening about all that open land and miles of road where you can see everything and still have absolutely nowhere to go.



The Ending Is Cruel, and It Works


The Creeper works in a candlelit, old-fashioned workshop at the end of the film.

Then we get that ending. The old music is playing. The Creeper is back at his tools, doing his horrible little hobby. We hear Darry screaming, and when we finally see what happened to him, the creature is looking through the remains of Darry's face with Darry's eyes now part of his own body. That is a terrible image. And I mean terrible in the best horror-movie sense.


The final reveal centers on Darry's eyes, now incorporated into the Creeper.

It's bleak, and I'm fine with that. I don't need a happy ending. But think about how much Justin Long's eyes did for this performance, and then think about the Creeper taking those very eyes. That's a cruel, clever way to end this story.


That ending is burned in my head, just like the truck on the highway and the bodies stitched into the walls.



BLAKWATCH Verdict: 7.7/10


So where did I land? I still think Jeepers Creepers is one of the more interesting horror movies of its era. If I'm grading the horror alone, the atmosphere, the practical effects, the design of the Creeper, the suspense, those unforgettable images, I'm giving it an 8.9 out of 10. Justin Long also deserves a lot of credit. This man was acting his heart out.


But wow, there is a lot more bad writing here than I remembered. The repetition, the strange decisions, people not answering each other, and especially the way Darry and Trish treat Jezelle. It chipped away at how much I cared about them. And when your monster is this scary, imagine how much better the movie could be if I were also desperately rooting for the people he's chasing.


That's why the overall score is a 7.7 out of 10. Still a good movie. Still scary. Still one of the most visually memorable monsters I've ever seen. But on this rewatch, I couldn't overlook just how uneven the screenplay is.


I used to remember Jeepers Creepers mostly for how badly it scared me. Now I remember that too, but I can also see the things the movie gets wrong. The Creeper is still magnificent. Some of the people around him? Not so much.



You May Also Like




Comments


Each Nine Teach Nine - Helping Online Entrepreneurs

VIRGINIA BEACH, VIRGINIA UNITED STATES

COPYRIGHT 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

**Disclosure: Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you purchase through one of these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases**

bottom of page